Ok, wait.

Maybe it's not totally me. We just went through the calibration test and mine is not that off, however my laptop doesn't have a contrast setting and isn't responding to the gamma adjustment. Lame! Darren's was really, really off though. Now he's complaining that everything looks washed out, but at least we're seeing pretty much the same thing.

Here's a good online tool if you're not sure whether your monitor is set correctly:
http://www.photofriday.com/calibrate.php